10 Favorite Garden Catalogs
January 17th, 2012
I like to shop locally and support Pennsylvania small businesses whenever possible. But sometimes I’m looking for offbeat stuff or unusual varieties that I can only get online or via mail-order.

Five of my favorite seed catalogs.
An excellent web site for consumer reviews of these and just about all other mail-order companies is the Dave’s Garden website. It has a “Garden Watchdog” service with ratings and reviews that’s akin to a Better Business Bureau for gardening.
Here are 10 of my favorite mail-order companies (and by the way, I don’t get any commissions, kickbacks, or other earnings by mentioning them):
1.) Baker Creek Heirloom Seeds, Mansfield, Missouri. 417-924-8917.
This down-home company has become THE source for all things heirloom. The flagship seed catalog is loaded not only with great old-time, non-Frankenfood varieties (the ‘Ali Baba’ watermelon from Iraq, the alien-looking ‘Reisetomate’ tomato, the variegated ‘Fish’ hot pepper) but some edible oddities you’ve probably never seen, like the Chinese red noodle bean, the jelly melon (an African cucumber-like fruit) and the ‘Rat’s Tail’ radish (has edible seed pods).
The paper catalog is more of a book with the best photography of any catalog out there. It’s earned a top spot on the prestigious Dave’s Garden Watchdog Top 30 of all companies.
2.) Pinetree Garden Seeds, New Gloucester, Maine. 207-926-3400.
This has been one of my main go-to seed companies for years. What I especially like is the family-owned company specializes in smaller packets at lower prices, which is ideal for experimenters and those with small gardens.
The selection isn’t as broad as some catalogs, but the service is good, and the seeds are good. It’ll hold down your costs, and give you better quality than the dirt-cheap, poor-quality choices sometimes found at bargain outlets. Pinetree offers both edibles and flowers.
3.) J.W. Jung Seed Co., Randolph, Wisconsin. 800-297-3123.
This one’s a mainstream choice and from the same company that runs the Totally Tomatoes, Vermont Bean Seed, and R.H. Shumway Seeds catalogs. It’s been another of my long-time go-to seed suppliers for its good seeds, good selection, and decent prices (although higher lately than they used to be).
Jung offers a mix of vegetables and flowers and does a particularly good job of picking out the latest and greatest varieties. I’ve always received what I ordered quickly.






