How Native Do You Have to Go to Make the Birds and Bees Happy?
July 27th, 2021
The designers of Penn State Arboretum’s new Pollinator and Bird Garden leaned heavily on research to determine the features, layout, and plant selection of this three-acre garden, which opened last month just down Park Avenue from Beaver Stadium.
Spots of it are very colorful already.
But what struck me during my opening-day visit was that almost all of the showiest plants were non-native perennials – yarrow, Russian sage, catmint, salvia, and one of my favorite summer perennials, betony ‘Hummelo’ with its long-lasting flower spikes of pinkish-purple.
What gives? Aren’t we supposed to be planting native plants if we want to attract pollinators?
Well, yes and no.
Just about everybody agrees that on the whole, native plants are the best bet for attracting the most bees, pollinating insects, birds, and hummingbirds.
It’s hard to go wrong pollinator-wise if you load up the yard on nothing but natives.
But the message that not everybody is getting is that many non-native plants – especially perennials – are also useful to pollinators.
Dr. Douglas Tallamy, author of the ground-breaking “Bringing Nature Home” book (Timber Press, $19.95, 2009) says that of the top 50 pollinator-attracting perennials, 34 of them are U.S. natives… which means that 16 are not.
That’s important because of the not-always-mentioned fact that a lot of native perennials just aren’t that great-looking to people.
Some have unimpressive blooms, some have floppy, “messy” growth habits, many look “beat-up” at times (usually from the feeding activities of the desired pollinators), and some seed around to the point of weediness.
When people aren’t expecting that and/or aren’t OK with that, the result can be a bad experience and a return to the traditional lawn.
“The truth is a lot of pollinator plants are not that exciting to people,” said Dr. Harland Patch, a Penn State entomologist who’s director of pollinator programming at Penn State Arboretum. “So what we’ve done is interplant good pollinator plants with the best of the non-natives… Purism is not the point of this.”