Full and Fuller
May 31st, 2022
I’ve seen a big shift these last few years in what gardeners view as the “best,” or at least the “desired,” way to garden.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93f01/93f01f96e15698b04a01e67a2fca4e6ab44df3ac" alt=""
Naturalistic gardens like this back-yard one in York County are trendy lately.
The trend is strongly toward a natural look in which lots of different plants intermingle and grow in laissez-faire masses – similar to how plants grow in the wild.
That’s in contrast to the more formal, tended look that’s been the landscape norm for decades. In that style, order reigns supreme, and every plant has its space… with a neat carpet of mulch underneath and between.
Whether you call it a meadow or a cottage garden or a naturalistic landscape, the loosely regulated, action-packed look has the common thread of a tremendously full planting.
Bare soil doesn’t show its face in these gardens – at least not during the growing season.
Traditional spacing guidelines are out the window, replaced by packing as much in as possible and letting self-seeding fill in the rest.
So much is going on in these gardens that they’re season-long riots of color and texture.
Several factors are converging to fuel this “new naturalism,” as author Kelly Norris calls it.
One is the message about helping pollinators. Concerned about the plight of bees and butterflies, many gardeners are acting on the petition of popular authors like Dr. Doug Tallamy, Rick Darke, Thomas Rainer, Claudia West, Piet Oudolf, Larry Weaner and others to plant not just for cosmetics but with an eye on benefiting ecosystems and the wildlife in it.
Related to that is the boom in native plants, which is being fed by concerns of invasive plants bumping out native species that local wildlife needs to survive.
And a third factor is that people are tired of spraying, trimming, mulching, and mowing big lawns. They see the loose approach as less work and welcome the idea of yards that are better able to care for themselves.
These tightly-packed, naturalistic gardens deliver on a variety of fronts.
For sure, they’re much more diverse than the traditional landscape of yew bushes, azaleas, a few daylilies, and a pear tree or two.