Should We Be Cutting Back on Peat Moss?
April 5th, 2022
Peat moss has long been our go-to, store-bought, plant-growing medium, useful for everything from starting seeds to growing potted plants to “lightening” our lousy clay soil.
But its widespread use is under fire lately as some argue that gardeners should move away from peat moss altogether for environmental and climate-change reasons.
The main issue is that peat moss serves as a super-sponge when it comes to soaking up carbon that otherwise would end up in Earth’s warming atmosphere.
Although peat bogs cover just 3 percent of the Earth’s surface, they store more carbon than all other vegetation types in the world combined – including trees – according to International Union for the Conservation of Nature.
Harvesting peatland bogs reduces that layer and sends peat out in forms that are burned as fuel or that quickly decompose in gardens, releasing the stored carbon into the air.
Fossil fuels also are burned in harvesting and transporting all of the peat, plus harvesting reduces a natural land use that harbors rich biodiversity, mitigates drought, and heads off wildfires.
The whole issue is especially heated in Great Britain, which is phasing in a ban on most forms of garden-use peat after some 90 percent of its once expansive network of peat bogs has been harvested or degraded.
Some in Britain, including the Royal Horticultural Society and its best known gardener, TV celebrity Monty Don, are doubling down on a quick end to peat use in gardening.
Don, for example, calls peat-harvesting “eco-vandalism” and flat-out says, “Gardeners should not be using peat… There is no need. There are plenty of alternatives to peat.”
Here as there (and despite the alternatives), it’s not easy convincing gardeners to give up such a staple product – especially considering that not even the horticulture industry and many of its leading experts and growers are convinced this is something we need to do.